Skip to content

Works of Islamic scholarship — free to read, free to keep

ihussain
4
English

Inevitable Doubt: Two Theories of Shi‘ Jurisprudence

by Robert Gleave

Language
English
Pages
138
PDF size
19.9 MB

About this book

Title: Inevitable Doubt: Two Theories of Shi‘ Jurisprudence

Author: Robert Gleave

Publisher: Brill

This is a monograph designed for advanced students. This book examines the works of two scholars on opposite ends of the Akhbari/Usuli debate in the 18th century: Al-Bahrani’s Akhbari al-Hada’iq al-nadira fi ahkam al’itra al-tahira and Al-Bihbani’s Usuli al-Fawa’id al-ha’riyya. Although the two works were not directly related to each other (i.e., one is not a response to the other), Gleave is able to distill their arguments and provide them in a manner that is logical for the reader. Broadly speaking, the difference between the two schools can be summed up by a difference in approach to knowledge and certainty. Gleave argues that Bahrani’s approach was driven by caution (although required more acceptance of reports by the Imams), whereas Bihbahani’s approach was driven by achieving probabilistic knowledge.

Reader reviews

–No reviews yet

Share this book

A bad scan, a missing page or the wrong author? Report a problem with this book

Read next

Related works